Modeling and analysis of market share dynamics in a duopoly subject to affine feedback advertising policies and delays

Presents extensions of the Vidale-Wolfe and Lanchester models for market share duopoly dynamics. The novelties in the proposed extensions are the explicit introduction of a set of undecided clients into existing models, which consider only the sets of clients of the two competing firms, as well as the use of decentralized affine feedback advertising policies. It is shown that, under the proposed class of advertising policies, the extended Vidale-Wolfe and Lanchester models, despite having different dynamics, have equilibria in identical locations, with the same stability properties. The introduction of a third set of undecided clients also motivates the introduction of a more elaborate model of market share dynamics based on the replicator-mutator model from evolutionary game theory. This is done by identifying strategies with the entries of a preference matrix consisting of the choice preferences of firms by clients and the mutation matrix representing transition probabilities from one set of clients to another. The proposed model is analysed with respect to equilibria and their stability properties, as well as parametric sensitivity, under the proposed advertising policies. All proposed models are analysed for stability, the presence of oscillations, existence of Hopf bifurcations when implementation or adoption delays are introduced. The extended models of Vidale-Wolfe and Lanchester are robust to implementation delays, while for adoption delays, bifurcations can occur. The proposed replicator-mutator model is robust for both types of delays. ; Apresenta extensões aos modelos de Vidale-Wolfe e Lanchester para a dinâmica de duopólios. As novidades nas extensões propostas são a introdução explícita de um conjunto de clientes indecisos nos modelos existentes, os quais consideram apenas os conjuntos de clientes das duas empresas concorrentes, e o uso de políticas de publicidade afins com realimentação. Demonstra-se que sob a classe proposta de políticas de publicidade, os modelos estendidos de Vidale-Wolfe e ...